what NOT to do

In this class, we are focusing a lot on what tools to use. But what about what tools not to use? As a future educator, I think incorporating technology is extremely important. However, I think it is just as important to know what technology should not be incorporated.

My mom works for the Gering Public School District as a K-12 Innovative Teaching and Learning Specialist. That’s fancy speak for being their educational techie. She is also back in the classroom teaching this year and using her class as a model for the other teachers so they can see how to use technology in the classroom. She is in charge of helping teachers incorporate technology in the classroom. She has also presented at multiple educational technology conferences across the country, and is a Google Certified Teacher and a Google Certified Trainer. Due to all this, I am pretty confident that she knows what she’s talking about when it comes to technology. While thinking about this assignment, I thought about how much technology we can incorporate into classrooms that I could research. Then I started thinking that, while technology is great, there are also things that should not be incorporated. So, I went to my mom to ask her what she thought was the worst. Without skipping a beat, she said Class Dojo was the worst. Now, I have heard her talk about Class Dojo, but I haven’t ever really paid attention to it, so it’s a great start for researching.

From the outside, Class Dojo doesn’t look like too horrible of a concept. Reward students for their participation, create profiles, create a “positive culture,” etc. The website does a very good job of making Class Dojo look like the greatest classroom product ever. The downside? It can completely destroy a child’s self-esteem. Class Dojo has a negative emotional impact on students. It is a digital version of a clip chart, and teachers can cast it up on the projector for all the other students to see. Not only do other students get to see how well or poorly their peers are doing. This is detrimental to a student’s self esteem. The basis of this program isn’t to build students up, but to guilt them into good behavior by turning students into nothing more than a number. Instead of giving face to face affirmation for good behavior, it is taking the human element out of one more aspect of teaching. It is way more effective to tell a student they’re doing a good job or give them a real high five than to passively put points on an app. Same thing goes for negative behavior. Instead of just taking off points from an app, take a second and pull the student aside and see why they’re misbehaving. Maybe there is something going on in their life outside of school, maybe they’re just having a bad day. You won’t ever know that if you take the passive route and take points off their profile every time they talk to their neighbor.

Another issue is that it indirectly punishes students that are a little more on the shy side. While students who are more outgoing are rewarded for little things like raising their hand, the more reserved students are stuck not gaining points. Also, there is way too much parental involvement with Class Dojo. Parents are able to see their student’s profile throughout the day. While parental involvement is important, parents should not be able to track their child’s profile like that throughout the day. This could lead to parents becoming upset with their children over nothing. There is such a thing as over involvement of parents.

Class Dojo is a prime example of why teachers need to think before they use a product. Just because it looks like it could be a good idea doesn’t mean it is. Teachers, and everyone for that matter, need to research what products they use before using it.

References:

Featured Image CC Kurt Voelker

Education Dreamer

For the Love of Learning

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “what NOT to do

  1. Great idea on writing a blog on what technologies not to use in the classroom! Taking a flip on what to use in the classroom was awesome. I have never heard of class dojo, but if it is anything like a clip chart showing what kids were the best and what kids were the worst that day, I am completely against it. I understand the reward of being the best kid, but like you said the shy kids, who were good students, are punished and embarrassed. I also do not like that parents being so involved. I think a parent should be involved with helping a student with homework, and being involved at parent teacher conferences. The rest should be up to the teacher on when they feel the need to involve the parent. It is important for students to have responsibilities and learn that their parents are not going to be around for every little thing in their lives. It helps the students be accountable for their actions. All in all, great article.

    Like

    1. Thanks so much. I was friends with this group of kids whose mom was one of the overly involved parents. She is a prime example of why parents should not be THAT involved in their childrens’ school lives. While I loved my friends, they couldn’t be self-sufficient to save their lives because their mom was always there holding their hands, which is exactly what Class Dojo promotes.

      Like

  2. I have been in a classroom where the teacher uses Class Dojo and when I was there I thought it looked pretty neat, but the more I read through your post here I agree with the downsides of it. Why punish kids who are shy? We need to stay away from a “technology teacher” and continue to maintain that person-to-person interaction.

    Like

    1. I felt the same way when I was reading the description on the product’s website. All throughout in school I’ve been one of the shy kids. However, just because a child is shy doesn’t mean that they are dumb or need to be punished. Quietness does not equal stupidity or outright unwillingness to participate.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. You’ve got a great perspective! Sometimes we get so focused on what we can/should do, especially in regards to technology, that we forget to warn each other about what NOT to use. It’s just as important, and sometimes it’s super helpful to break apart what doesn’t work and see why it’s a poor tool, so that we can better analyze and improve the tools we have that are useful.

    Also, I love your theme! Dark backgrounds and light text are a favorite of mine.

    Like

    1. Thanks! I was a graphic design major before I switched so I’ve enjoyed being able to play with the settings on here. And yeah, with how many tools are out there it’s important to know what to avoid.

      Like

  4. I agree with your post on every level. I really like that you decide to go on the side of what not to use. We see so many great examples of technology a bad one can slip by unnoticed. You set a great example of bad technology with Dojo. I had never heard of it before so thanks for the good advice! It sounds terribly demeaning.

    Like

  5. I really enjoyed this blog, especially with the dojo part. I do not agree with punishing kids for being shy, as I always struggled with being shy in school and had a hard time with presenting things

    Like

    1. Thanks Emily. I was the same way all through school before college and still am a little shy even now. As long as students are putting in effort and passing their classes, they shouldn’t be punished.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s